Why traditional secrets management no longer works for modern teams

Secrets management used to be straightforward when everything was in one controlled environment. Teams could rely on manual processes and simple tools to keep things secure. But as engineering teams build and deploy applications faster, across multiple environments, and with increasing complexity, those old methods start to break down.

What worked when your team was smaller, and infrastructure was simpler doesn’t hold up at scale. Whether you're growing quickly or juggling multiple projects with limited resources, outdated secrets management can introduce security risks and slow your team down.

Want a deeper dive into the future of secrets management? Our 2025 Future of Secrets Management white paper explores the latest trends, challenges, and innovations shaping how teams handle secrets at scale.

Read the White Paper

TL;DR

Traditional secrets management methods, manual processes, hardcoded credentials, and scattered configurations are no longer sufficient for modern engineering teams. They create security risks, inefficiencies, and scaling issues. To stay secure and scale, teams need to automate secrets rotation, implement granular access controls, centralize storage, and integrate modern tools into CI/CD pipelines. Modernizing secrets management empowers teams to move quickly, stay secure, and scale without bottlenecks.

The problem with traditional secrets management

As teams grow and applications become more complex, manual secrets management creates problems. Hardcoded credentials, inconsistent access controls, and scattered secrets make development slower and less secure. Here’s where these traditional approaches fall short and what it means for your team.

Manual and error-prone processes

How many times have you seen .env files shared in Slack or API keys stored directly in repositories? It's easy to overlook these practices in the rush to get things done, but the truth is:

• Human error is a big factor. We all make mistakes, and a single typo or missed update can expose a critical secret.
• Managing secrets manually across dev, staging, and production environments quickly becomes a game of catch-up, creating inconsistencies between environments.
• Secrets scattered around repositories, local machines, and cloud services make it nearly impossible to track what's exposed and increase security risks.

Scaling challenges

As applications evolve and teams scale, secrets management has to scale too. But traditional methods aren't built for today's teams' growing needs. They quickly become:

• Inefficient. The more services and environments you have, the more manual updates and management is required, which slows down development.
• Fragile. Hardcoding secrets or manually updating them across services leaves your infrastructure exposed to errors.
• Time-consuming. Every secret update adds more work for your team, eating into valuable development time

Limited access controls and visibility

Teams often store secrets in shared locations with minimal control over who can access them. Without strong access controls, this leads to:

• Developers, contractors, or even CI/CD systems having more access to secrets than they need
• Lack of visibility into who has accessed or modified a secret, let alone why or when.
• Difficulty in enforcing strong access control policies required by compliance regulations like GDPR or SOC 2.

Security and compliance risks

The stakes are higher than ever when it comes to secrets management. With sensitive credentials scattered across systems and services, the risks are significant:

• Manual rotation or outdated credentials are a weak point in your security strategy
• Plaintext secrets or misconfigured storage can expose critical information to unauthorized access.
• Ensuring secrets management meets industry standards isn't just about checking a box. It requires automated processes that traditional methods can't deliver.

How modern teams can modernize secrets management

While traditional secrets management practices clearly present significant challenges, this begs the question: How do modern teams adapt to the realities of today's development process and scale effectively?

Automate secrets rotation and updates

Manual updates and hardcoded credentials simply don't cut it anymore. Automation should be at the heart of your secrets management. With automated secret rotation, credentials are always up to date, reducing the chance of human error and eliminating the need for manual tracking. This is the foundation for secure, scalable management in a fast-moving environment.

Implement granular access control

As your team and infrastructure grow, so should your access controls. Gone are the days of blanket permissions. Modern tools let you define specific access rights for each user, contractor, or CI/CD system; ensuring that everyone only has access to the secrets they need to do their job. This also makes it easier to track who's accessing what, providing full visibility and helping meet compliance standards.

Centralize secret storage

No more scattered secrets across local machines, repositories, or cloud services. A centralized, secure storage solution ensures your secrets are stored in one place, making tracking, updating, and managing them more manageable. This organization reduces the chances of leaks and makes secrets management simpler as your infrastructure grows.

Scale without the extra complexity

As your projects evolve, you need solutions that can keep up. Modern secrets management tools easily integrate into your CI/CD pipelines and scale with your infrastructure. No more adding complexity or taking on extra manual work. These tools automate the processes that used to take up valuable time, giving your team the flexibility to scale securely without the growing pains.

Transitioning to modern secret management

Secrets management should be an enabler, not a bottleneck. Modernizing your approach empowers your team to move quickly, stay secure, and scale without compromise. The old way of doing things won't keep up. Adapting to modern practices is the key to staying ahead in today's fast-paced development environment.